Thin-layer chromatography (TLC) is a most flexible and versatile chromatographic technique and therefore remains an indispensable
tool for many applications. Applications range from monitoring of chemical reactions, comparison of fractions, and preparative
separations to qualitative analyses such as identification of raw materials, tests for adulterations, and detection of biological
activity to demanding quantitative determinations including assays, impurity profiling, and cleaning validation. In addition
to traditional TLC plate development in an enclosed tank, there are also gradient and even forced flow techniques now available.
The variety of stationary phases for planar separations is quite large, and it would be difficult to cover the subject comprehensively
in this column. Therefore, in the present coverage, we will focus only on TLC plates used in the state-of-the-art qualitative
and quantitative high-performance separations. For a more general approach, we recommend the corresponding chapters of the
books edited by Sherma (1) and Nyiredy (2). Previous issues of LCGC have covered various aspects of modern TLC (3–7). This present contribution will serve to bring readers up to date on the
latest developments in stationary phases.
Modern TLC is a powerful, reliable, and GLP–GMP (good laboratory practices–good manufacturing practices) compliant analytical
technique that depends strongly on the commercial availability of high-quality, precoated plates. For many years, such plates
have been on the market, featuring different formats, stationary phases, binders, and supports. Worldwide sales are increasing
steadily, and users find it difficult to decide which of the many TLC products to select. This month's installment of "Column
Watch" provides an overview of modern plates for TLC, their properties, applications, and performance from a theoretical and
also a practical point of view. Although much lower in cost, self-made plates usually cannot compete with commercial plates
with regards to stability, performance, homogeneity, and batch-to-batch consistency.
There are a number of official TLC regulatory methods, for example, in the international pharmacopoeias, the food laws, and
in the collection of official methods of AOAC International. Many of those methods are rather old and their description of
the TLC plate is often inadequate: "Use a plate coated with a suitable silica gel." Even though in official methods, a general
suitability test can be given, it still remains difficult to select the proper plate because the expected results are not
always precisely described. Therefore, a secondary focus of this article is on the important features of modern TLC plates,
which affect the reproducibility of the chromatographic experiment.
Theoretical ConsiderationsTypes of plates: Format, support, layer, and binder: Precoated TLC plates on a glass support are available in numerous formats, of which 20 cm × 20 cm usually is considered
the standard for classical TLC. Glass plates are very sturdy and can be developed in vertical and horizontal mode without
bending, thus ensuring consistent movement of the mobile phase on the plate. They are fully inert when used with most solvents
and derivatizing agents and therefore are considered universally applicable. The optimum separation (migration) distance on
these TLC plates is 12–15 cm. If only a few samples are to be separated at a time on the same plate, smaller formats such
as 10 cm × 20 cm or 5 cm × 20 cm (20 cm in the direction of development), which also accommodate the optimum migration distance,
are available. If optimum separation efficiency is fairly unimportant (for example, if the sample contains only one or very
few components), developing distance can be reduced to about 8 cm and the plate format 20 cm × 10 cm (or fractional plates
as small as 2.5 cm × 10 cm) might be sufficient.
For various reasons, plastic- or aluminum-backed plates (probably better called foils or sheets) also have become popular.
These plates are usually less expensive than glass plates and can be cut conveniently into any size. When handled properly,
their performance is comparable to that of glass plates, but TLC sheets require much more attention during sample application,
chromatogram development, and particularly during derivatization. These precautions are necessary because of their inherent
flexibility and somewhat limited tolerance to chemicals and heat.